MUMBAI: Taher Merchant and Feroze Khan, two of the five convicts in the 1993 Mumbai serial blasts case, on Thursday sentenced to death by a special Terrorist and Disruptive Activities (Prevention) Act court. Two others, Abu Salem, Karimullah Khan  life in jail. Another convict, Riyaz Siddiqui 10 years in jail.

On March 12, 1993, serial blasts in the city killed 257 and left over 713 injured.

The sentencing comes after extensive arguments made by the prosecution and defence since June 16 when the court had convicted Salem, Merchant, Feroze and Karimullah on charges of criminal conspiracy , murder and indulging in acts of terrorism that cause death. Siddiqui found guilty on the lesser charge for abetting and aiding terrorism.

CBI

While CBI special public prosecutor Deepak Salvi sought the death sentence for Merchant, Feroze and Karimullah, he pressed for life sentences against Salem and Merchant.

The charge against Salem could have attracted the maximum punishment. But since he was extradited from Portugal in 2005, a Lisbon court has held that he cannot awarded death here. Salem, though his lawyer, has also argued that he cannot jailed for more than 25 years as assured by the Indian government.

Key conspirator Mustafa Dossa, 60, against whom Salvi had also sought the death penalty, died pending sentencing. The case against him has since abated and there no sentence pronounced against him.

Qayyum Shaikh

Qayyum Shaikh, 64, behind bars for almost 11 years,acquitted for lack of evidence. This trial of seven was the second in the 1993 case.
The main trial of 123 accused ended in 2006 with the conviction of 100. Yakub Memon, brother of prime absconding accused Tiger Memon, hanged in 2015, and the others have served or are serving time.
Salvi said trial for the seven, arrested between 2003 and 2010, had to separated as they were nabbed after a substantial portion of the previous trial was completed. With no other accused currently in custody, the verdict will be the last in the case for now. Thirty-three accused are absconding, including key conspirators Dawood Ibrahim, his brother Anees Ibrahim, Mustafa’s brother Mohammed Dossa and Tiger Memon.

22 judgments of the Supreme Court

For Merchant and Karimullah, the Central Bureau of Investigation (CBI) had relied on the same 22 judgments of the Supreme Court which it used for seeking the extreme punishment for Dossa and Feroz. Prominent in the verdicts which Salvi said gave sentencing “guidelines” was the landmark verdict in 2013 in the very 1993 blasts when the apex court had confirmed death sentence for the “archer” Yakub Memon, while commuting it for ten others, who it described as “arrows.”
Condemning both, Merchant and Karimullah, for being “main conspirators” in the Mumbai blasts of ’93, Salvi stressed on how Merchant “worked with Tiger Memon”. He backed his death plea by pointing to “anguish, agitation and frustration expressed by Taher Merchant due to the situation prevailing in Mumbai during the period riots in January, 1993”. He continued that Merchant proven guilty of “actively participating in several meetings” and “must held directly responsible for the bomb explosions which deeply rooted in the conspiracy discussed in various meetings in Dubai”.

Ejaz Pathan gang

Similarly, Karimullah’s role as a member of the Ejaz Pathan gang and his active role in the landing of arms and ammunitions in Shakhadi pointed out by Salvi. Both accused had knowledge of the “object of the conspiracy” but did not avert the crime although they had the chance to do so, pointed out Salvi, as one of the aggravating factor. That he had absconded was another aggravating factor. “The victims and their families were denied justice by the inordinate delay of 24 years as he remained absconding”